i had one about 6lb from firs lake at the oaks fishing tight to the ariator. ariators are obviously a hot spots for them because the ariator will put more oxygen in the water when its turned on and also gives it a bit of flow, the same day my dad was just behind me on oaks lake fishing towards another ariator and was getting one a chuck on paste, only small ones though around 1.5lb. barbel in commercials dont have the same class as ones from a river and seem to lose quite a bit of there golden colour, all the ones ive had have nearly been silver. still beautiful fish though and mean scrappers.